Assumptions, presumptions, and agency…

littlemissbratty:

Omg you’ve been horribly abused in some of your pictures. Especially the one where your behind is a bloody mess. You deserve so much more. I understand this is a fetish, but wow, that broke my heart to see someone hurt another so badly. I can’t imagine how painful that must have been for you not just during it, but for days or even weeks later. Hope you realize how beautiful you are and that you deserve so much better than these type of sex fetishes.💕

I’m going to list 3 types of people:

  • Vanilla people who just see abuse
  • 50 shades groupies who see a bit of spanking as fun, but anything more is abuse
  • Masochists

Now I’m unsure if you are the first or the second example. The fact you’ve stumbled across my blog makes me think you’re the second, but who knows.

I am the third. I am a masochist, and I am a submissive.

Do I need to explain what a masochist is? I enjoy pain. I ADORE bruises. That photo you are referring to was done for fun, MY fun, as well as theirs. It wasn’t even that painful if I’m honest, and I loved it. I look back on those pics and smile.

Despite you calling me beautiful, what you have done is make me feel like shit, you come to my blog and decide that you’re going to try and tell me I deserve better- yes, I deserve far better than being told to feel ashamed of myself and who I am. YOU have shamed me.

I hate separating my 2 partners but I’m going to.

You see a few pics of my beaten butt and you scream abuse and think I need saving. Did you see when I was in hospital, dozens of times because of my chronic condition, did you see me coming out of surgery and Daddy holding the straw to my mouth to get me drinking? Or lifting tiny morsels of food to my lips to get me eating? Do you see him coming home from a full days work and starting on dinner because I can’t move? Do you see any of that?

Or how about Mister, we don’t live together but he’d do all that too. In fact when I have bad days, do you see him spend 5 hours on FaceTime with me whilst he’s working, just so he can keep me company? Do you see him, every single day, checking I’ve eaten and taken my meds?

You tell me I’m beautiful, after shaming who I am and making me feel crap about myself, whereas he has had me saying mantras into the mirror for the last few days, until I start believing that I really am beautiful, until I start believing him.

When I’ve had a bad day and told Mister I wish he could sing to me, do you know what he did? He recording him singing, have you seen 3 men and a baby? You know where they sing “Goodnight sweetheart”? That. He sung that to me just before bedtime to help calm my head.

You’re right, I am worth more than a bloody butt- I’m worth all that they give me. I’m worth all their love.

This is who I am. This is what I want. Please don’t go around telling people they are being abused when they are very clearly happy and love what they do.

I love these men so much, and they love me. We are so much more than the few pics we decide to share- can you imagine how much love and trust there is to do what we do?

Everything is consensual, I have limits which have always been respected, I have a safe word, which again will always be respected. On top of that, any of us, at any point, can say actually I don’t want any kink right now, and it will stop- the kink will stop, but the relationships will continue, because guess what?

We are more than “just” the kink you see, and although we’d miss it, we love each other and that is stronger. So if I wanted to take a break from kink, I know that my partners would respect that and still be right beside me.

There’s a huge difference between saying

  • You are being abused
  • Are you being abused

It’s important to inquire because sometimes hells yeah they’re being abused.!  Only one of those sentences respects and acknowledges the other person’s agency.  Even an actual victim’s agency, which, incidentally makes it even more important to give them their agency!

Important clue: if you walk up to an abused person and say “you’re abused” you want to guess what they’re going to say somewhere between nine times out of ten and 99 times out of 100?  “I’m fine!”

Adults in abuse are rarely given choices by their abusers.  Their agency is taken away from them.  That’s why you taking away their agency by making declarations on their “behalf” isn’t just rude but unworkable.

So let’s not do that.  If you believe someone’s being abused that’s a serious, red-letter situation.  For goodness sake don’t just assume they’re cheerful masochists either! But regardless please have enough courtesy respect for them that you ask and listen and don’t just tell.


Big, big hat’s off to @littlemissbratty for clarifying the difference between Submission and Masochism.  First because they’re not the same thing – LMB is very clear that they’re both, not one or the other.  But second because in the hierarchy of these things those fucking Shades of Grey “D/S” relationships are far more likely to be abusive than simple S&M ones.

A pure Sadist wants to hurt someone but not control them.  A pure Masochist gets off on pain but may have exactly zero tolerance for being controlled.  (In fact I’ve met scary-dominant Masochists and deeply submissive Sadists.)  Of course in reality there are very few “pure” kinksters.  BDSM isn’t just an alphabet or even a spectrum, it’s a gloriously messy artist’s palette of possibilities.